Comparison of the Two Methods for the Analysis of Petiole Nitrate Nitrogen Concentration in Irrigated Cotton
J.H. Smith, Soil, Water and Environmental Science
J.C. Silvertooth, Plant Sciences Department
E.R. Norton, Plant Sciences Department
A study was conducted in Arizona in 1997 with the objective of analyzing
the accuracy of a recently developed portable nitrate meter (Cardy meter) to
effectively measure petiole nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N) in irrigated
cotton (Gossypium ssp.). This task was accomplished by performing
correlation and linear regression analyses on NO3-N concentrations
of cotton petiole sap, as measured by the Cardy meter, against the standard
procedure NO3-N analysis, as measured by an ion selective electrode (ISE).
Results revealed that the NO3-N concentrations of petiole
sap were highly correlated with dried petiole NO3-N (pearson correlation
coefficient = 0.96, P < 0.0001). A regression equation with
an r2 = 0.92 was derived: Y = 9.96X - 1170.86, where X and Y
are NO3-N in petiole sap (ppm) and dried petioles (ppm),
respectively. These results suggest that the sap analysis using the
Cardy meter is a potentially valuable tool to monitor the in-season N status of irrigated cotton.
Efficient nitrogen (N) management is essential to achieving optimum yields
in cotton (Gossypium spp.) production. Due to the dynamic nature of
cotton growth, decisions need to be made promptly and effectively regarding N
rates and times of applications. For instance, N in excess of that needed for
optimum lint yield can lead to excessive vegetative growth and delayed maturity
(Tewolde et. al, 1995). Deficiencies experienced at the time of maximum crop
demand can result in lint yield reductions. A technique available to managing
in-season N inputs efficiently in terms of economic, agronomic, and environmental
concerns can be accomplished by monitoring the in season NO3-N
status of the plant using petiole analysis.
Gardner and Tucker (1967) first established the foundation for the
utilization of petioles as a N management tool for irrigated cotton in the desert Southwest. The traditional method of
petiole NO3-N analysis to determine plant N status involves numerous
steps, which can be costly and time-consuming (Baker and Smith, 1969). A portable
NO3- selective electrode (hereafter referred to as the Cardy meter) has
recently been developed that can directly measure NO3- present in fresh
samples of expressed petiole sap. This Cardy meter offers immediate results
of in-season crop N status. Therefore, adjustments in N fertilization can be made
before the crop experiences N deficiencies or excessive N applications are made
that may lead to enhanced vegetative growth, yield reductions, and/or delayed maturity.
The accuracy of portable NO3- meters has been examined in the
past by testing the correlation between NO3-N concentrations determined by
sap analysis and NO3-N concentrations determined by dried petiole
analysis. Hodges and Baker (1993) used cotton to compare the differences in the two
methods. They found good correlations (r = 0.88) for early sampling periods, but
poor correlations for late sampling periods. They found that the NO3-N concentrations
measured in the petiole sap extracts increased relative to those measured in the
dried petioles during later stages of growth, and concluded that this may
be a result of the decrease in moisture content in mature cotton
plants. Hartz et al. (1994) compared petiole sap NO3-N using a
portable electrode with conventional dry tissue analysis for several vegetable
crops and obtained r2 values ranging from 0.65 to 0.89. Due to the slope
of the regression line differing significantly among crops, Hartz et al (1994)
emphasized the importance of determining the relationship for each
crop of interest. Kubota (1996) conducted a study towards evaluating the
accuracy of sap test for cauliflower and broccoli petiole NO3-N
determination in comparison to conventional dry tissue analysis. The design included 3 irrigation rates and 4 N applications. Regression coefficients
for the 3 irrigation rates did not differ significantly (P < 0.05), thus the
relationship between sap NO3-N and dried petiole NO3-N
was not effected by differences in crop water status.
Potential problems associated with the Cardy meter may result from poor
calibration, environmental conditions, and maintenance. Initial experiments
performed by Hodges and Baker, (1993) revealed that the meters were very sensitive
to temperature and sunlight. Life of the meter's sensor pads will vary depending
on environment and care. For example, initial measurements performed
under laboratory conditions in this study revealed that the sensor pads may
need replacement after approximately 260 samples.
In 1997, a study was initiated with the objective of analyzing the accuracy
of the Cardy meter to effectively measure NO3-N in cotton petioles
grown under irrigated conditions in the desert Southwest.
Materials and Methods
Field experiments evaluating various rates of N applications were
used as sampling sites in 1997. The experiments being conducted at these sites
offered a wide gradient in N fertility regimes and petiole NO3-N
experiments consisted of a N and PIXTM (N-PIX) experiment conducted
at the University of Arizona Marana Agricultural Center (MAR), and N management
experiments at both the MAR and Maricopa Agricultural Center (MAC). Both Upland
cotton (G. hirsutum L., var. DPL 33B) and American Pima (G. barbadense
L., var Pima S-7) were sampled at MAC. At MAR, only Upland cotton (DPL 33B and STV 474)
Routine petiole sampling from each experimental unit was performed on approximate
14 day intervals, from as early as the occurrence of the seventh node through
cut-out. Petioles were sampled from the uppermost, fully expanded mature
leaf, which generally fell in the vicinity of the fourth or fifth node below
the terminal. Approximately 50 petioles were randomly collected from each plot, mixed
thoroughly, and divided into two portions, dry and fresh. Fresh petioles
were immediately stored in sealed plastic bags, and transported on ice
in an insulated cooler from the field to the laboratory. The tissue of the
fresh petioles was subsequently crushed with a rolling pin to extract sap,
which was used for determining NO3-N concentrations. Four to
five drops of the extracted sap were placed directly on the sensor pad of a
Cardy nitrate meter for analyses (Horiba, Ltd., Kyoto, Japan). Two Cardy
meters were used simultaneously to assess improve accuracy and
precision of measurement. The Cardy meters were recalibrated using a two
point calibration after
every ten measurements or sooner if large differences between the two Cardy
meters were observed. Potassium nitrate (KNO3) standards of 150 and
2000 ppm NO3- were used to perform the calibrations. Nitrate measurements
as determined by the Cardy meter were converted to NO3-N for
subsequent regression analysis.
Dry petioles were oven dried at 65 ° C for 24 hours and then ground
to pass a 425 um (40 mesh) screen for prior to analysis. Dried petiole samples
were extracted with a 0.025 M Al2(SO4)3 buffer
solution containing 10 mg NO3-N L-1. The extraction process
involved the addition of 40 ml of the extracting solution to 400 mg of
dried sample and shaking the mixture for 15 minutes. Nitrate-N concentrations
of the filtered extract were determined by use of an ion selective electrode (ISE)
Regression and correlation analyses between the dry and fresh methods for NO3-N
determination were performed in accordance to procedures outlined by Gomez & Gomez (1984)
and the SAS Institute (SAS, 1996).
Results and Discussion
Correlation and linear regression analyses were performed on NO3-N
concentrations of cotton petiole sap, as measured by the Cardy meter, against dried
petiole NO3-N, as measured by the ISE. The results revealed that NO3-N
concentrations of petiole sap were highly correlated with dried petiole
NO3-N throughout the season (pearson correlation coefficient = 0.96, P
< 0.0001). The linear regression equation (Equation 1) was shown to be
highly significant (P < 0.0001):
Y = 9.96X - 1170.86 (n = 279, r2 = 0.92) (Eq.1)
where Y refers to the NO3-N in the dried petiole tissue (ppm), and
X refers to the NO3-N in the petiole sap (ppm). The standard errors
of the slope and intercept are ± 0.0413 and ± 235, respectively. Both
the slope and intercept are highly significant with P < 0.0001
In contrast to Hodges and Baker (1993), the NO3-N concentrations
in the petiole sap extracts measured in this study showed a consistent,
positive linear relationship with the dried petiole measurements throughout
the entire season (Fig.1). In this
study, we conducted petiole sampling from the occurrence of the seventh node
to cut-out, which provided samples with a range of 213.5 to 22, 485 ppm NO3-N.
In conclusion, these results demonstrate that sap NO3-N
concentrations as determined by the Cardy meter were well correlated with
dried petiole NO3-N analyzed by the traditional laboratory
method using dry, ground petioles. Therefore, the quick sap analysis using the
Cardy meter is a potentially valuable tool to monitor the in-season N status
of irrigated cotton in Arizona.
- Baker, A.S., and R. Smith. 1969. Extracting solution for potentiometric determination of nitrate in plant tissue. J. Agric. Food Chem. 17:1284-1287.
- Gardner, B.R., and T.C. Tucker. 1967. Nitrogen effects on cotton: II. Soil and petiole analysis. Soil Sci. Soc. Am. Proc. 31:785-791.
- Hartz, T.K., R.F. Smith, K.F. Schulbach, and M. LeStrange. 1994. On farm nitrogen tests improve fertilizer efficiency, protect groundwater. Calif. Agri. 48:29-32.
- Hodges, S.C., and S. Baker. 1993. Correlation of plant sap extracts of nitrate-N and K with dried petiole extracts. Proc. Beltwide Cotton Conf. National Cotton Council, Memphis, TN. p.1335-1337
- Kubota, A. 1996. Petiole sap nitrate tests for cauliflower and broccoli. M.S. Thesis; Department of Soil, Water, and Environmental Sciences, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ.
- SAS Institute. 1996. SAS/STAT: Procedures. Release 6.03 ed. SAS Inst., Cary, NC.
- Sunderman , H.D., A.B.Onken, and L.R. Hossner. 1979. Nitrate concentration of cotton petioles as influenced by cultivar, row spacing, and N application rate. Agron. J. 71:p.731-737.
- Tewolde, H., C.J. Fernandez, D.C. Foss, and L.G. Unruh, Jr.1995. Critical petiole nitrate-nitrogen for lint yield and enhanced maturity in pima cotton. Agron. J.87:223-227.
This is a part of publication AZ1006:
"Cotton: A College of Agriculture Report," 1998, College of Agriculture,
The University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona,
85721. Any products, services, or organizations that are mentioned, shown, or indirectly
implied in this publication do not imply endorsement by The University of Arizona.
The University is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer.
This document located at http://ag.arizona.edu/pubs/crops/az1006/az10068c.html
Return to Cotton 98 index